How did BelieversStandUnited.com get
started? What
is its connection with KCM and Kenneth and Gloria Copeland?
On November 7, 2007, Kenneth Copeland Ministries/Eagle
Mountain International Church ("KCM") received a letter
of inquiry from Iowa Senator Charles Grassley (the "Grassley
letter"). Senator Grassley is the ranking Republican
on the Senate Finance Committee. KCM was one of six
churches that received a Grassley letter. The Grassley
letters were sent only to churches that preach the Word of
Faith message. The media widely reported the Senator's
investigation of the "Grassley 6."
The names of the six churches that received a Grassley letter
are:
- Without Walls International Church (Revs. Paula and Randy
White)
- World Healing Center Church (Rev. Benny Hinn)
- Joyce Meyer Ministry (Revs. Joyce and David Meyer)
- New Birth Missionary Baptist Church (Bishop Eddie Long)
- World Changers Church International (Dr. Creflo Dollar)
- Eagle Mountain International Church (Revs. Kenneth and
Gloria Copeland)
Following
the reports of the Grassley inquiry, people from around the
country and all quarters of Christianity expressed concerns
about the impact of the investigation on the church and individual
believers. Many question why the inquiry was directly
targeted at six churches that preach the Word of Faith message. Others
wonder about the implications of the Grassley inquiry on
their denomination, church, minister and family.
BelieversStandUnited.com was created,
in part, to try to answer the questions and address the concerns
of the partners and friends of KCM and all believers around
the country about these recent actions by Senator Grassley.
What
does Believers Stand United do and what does it stand for?
Believers Stand United.com is
an educational website developed, hosted and sponsored
by Kenneth Copeland Ministries/Eagle Mountain International
Church ("KCM")
to help set the record straight about these important matters
and to give the public a voice in protecting religious liberties.
What
does it mean if I cast a vote in support of BSU? Will my
vote be counted, and how will it be used?
BSU is asking you to join us in protecting religious freedoms
by casting your vote on BSU. Please click VOTE YES! so
we can do the work of protecting the rights of all churches
and the whole Body of Christ.
By clicking VOTE YES! You
are stating your belief that Senator Grassley's inquiry
interferes with the Church's religious freedoms by demanding
to see private church documents and information and amount
to an inquiry into the very nature of a church's religious
beliefs and practices.
By clicking VOTE YES! You
are stating your concern that Senator Grassley's
investigation could ultimately have as much impact
on you and your ministry as it does on KCM or the
other five ministries that received a letter from
the Senator.
By clicking VOTE YES! You
are stating your concern that if Christ's followers
fail to defend the legal rights of the six churches
who received letters from Senator Grassley, then
it may be you and your church or your neighbor's
church that will be targeted next.
By clicking VOTE YES! You
are stating that all believers must now Stand United
to protect and defend religious freedoms from this unprecedented
challenge!
By clicking VOTE YES! You
are stating that now is the time for the Church to come
together to protect the religious freedoms that our forefathers
worked so hard to provide and protect.
Once BSU receives your electronic ballot of VOTE
YES!, we
will gather them together at KCM, pray over them, count
them, and then let the world know we are of one mind and
spirit about this important matter.
Why should I care about Senator
Grassley's investigation of these six churches and preachers?
For almost 200 years, our Government respected the sanctity
of the Church. However, since the 1960s the government
has demonstrated unprecedented willingness to strike
down long-held expressions of our religious faith:
- 1962 Prayer in the public schools struck
down
- 1963 Bible reading over
the intercom struck down
- 1989 Nativity scene inside
a government building struck down
- 1992 Prayer at public school
graduations struck down
- 2000 Prayer at high school
football games struck down
- 2005 Ten Commandments display
in a Kentucky courthouse struck down
Senator Grassley's investigation threatens to trespass
upon all of our religious liberties and strike
down the First Amendment
rights of the Church -- rights that are protected by long-standing
IRS procedures that allow the IRS to obtain answers to the
Senator's questions while respecting the Church's
constitutional rights.
Why did Senator Grassley single
out the six churches and their so- called "televangelist" leaders?
In statements to the press, Senator Grassley has indicated
that his questions were based on reports from watchdog groups,
whistleblowers, and the media. No substantiation has
been provided related to these reports. KCM believes
that the primary basis for Senator Grassley's inquiry
is information provided by Ole Anthony, the leader of the
self-proclaimed religious watchdog group, The Trinity Foundation.
Ole Anthony has a long-standing and personal animosity for
ministries that spread the Word of Faith message and, in
particular, for the six ministries targeted by Senator Grassley.
Are Kenneth and Gloria Copeland "televangelists"?
Kenneth and Gloria Copeland's ministry was birthed
out of love for people and a commitment to bring people the
Word of God. It is understandable why people would
consider them televangelists since they use television – among
other media – to teach the Word. At the end of
the day, everything they preach, every broadcast they come
on, everywhere they minister, everything they say and do
is prayed over, motivated, and designed to minister the Word
to the people.
What is the "Word of Faith" message?
Is KCM a Word of Faith ministry? Is the Word of Faith
message a legitimate Christian doctrine and theology?
The Word of Faith message is a long-standing Christian theology
that holds the belief that God wants His children to be spiritually,
physically, emotionally, and financially blessed, and that
prosperity in all areas of one's life is an outward
sign of the fulfillment of God's promises contained
in the Bible. KCM is a Word of Faith ministry.
Do Kenneth
and Gloria Copeland preach a "prosperity
gospel?"
The Copelands believe in the Word of God and that His Word
declares His desire to bless His people. They do teach
that God's blessings and prosperity apply to the spiritual,
physical, emotional and financial areas of one's life. These
blessings and prosperity are then to be used to bless others. But
Kenneth and Gloria would not describe their ministry as teaching
and preaching a "prosperity gospel," especially
if the term solely equates blessing to financial gain.
What
specifically has Senator Grassley asked for that KCM finds
objectionable? What is KCM's objection?
KCM has stated its specific
concerns to Senator Grassley's questions in its responses
to the Senator. A summary of KCM's responses to each of
the Senator's questions can be found here: Kenneth
Copeland Ministries Responds to Senate Finance Committee
(Summary) - December 6, 2007.
What does the Constitution say?
What does the "wall
of separation between church and state" mean?
The First Amendment states
that "Congress shall make
no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting
the free exercise thereof." The first
clause of the Amendment is known as the "establishment
clause," and the second clause is known as the "free
exercise clause." With respect to religion, the
First Amendment requires that the government be neutral,
preferring no beliefs above others.
On January 1, 1802, in a letter
to the Danbury Baptist Association, Thomas Jefferson first
used the phrase building a wall
of separation between the church and state. Jefferson's
wall was designed not just to prevent the Church from interfering
with the state, but also to prevent the state from interfering
with the Church. The selective investigation only of
Charismatic-Pentecostal churches that preach the "Word
of Faith" message raises significant concerns as to
whether the inquiry is aimed at publicly questioning the
religious beliefs of the targeted churches, their preachers,
and their members.
Has KCM answered Senator Grassley's questions?
Why doesn't KCM just give him what he has asked for so
he can see that KCM is not doing anything wrong?
KCM's response reflected a sincere and good faith
effort by the Church to provide answers to as many of the
Senator's questions as possible without compromising
the protections afforded to the Church by the United States
Constitution and the Internal Revenue Code. KCM provided
responses to 17 of the 42 questions Senator Grassley posed. KCM's
response consisted of:
- A 3-page cover letter from our counsel
- A 23-page question-by-question response
- 291 pages of exhibits
KCM provided detailed responses to the Senator's questions
that did not seek information that was private or otherwise
protected by federal law or the Constitution, but did not
provide certain private information about the ministry and
the operations and activities of the church. Where
KCM provided a partial answer or response, or did not answer
a question asked by Senator Grassley, the Church determined
that the question raised constitutional and/or statutorily
based privacy and confidentiality concerns.
In its response to the Senator,
KCM clearly stated its position that the most timely and
efficient manner for Senator Grassley to obtain the requested
information, without compromising the rights of the Church
and those persons associated with it, is to request the
information from the IRS. Such a request would be subject
to longstanding IRS church-inquiry procedures and confidentiality
protections under the Internal Revenue Code. These procedures
were enacted, at the suggestion of Senator Grassley himself,
in recognition of the potential for government investigations
into churches to infringe upon "the
civil liberties of churches."
At the end of a properly conducted church tax inquiry by
the IRS, Senator Grassley could request the IRS to send him
the information the IRS obtains through the church tax inquiry.
By proceeding in this manner, Senator Grassley would have
access to the information he is seeking, but would not be
able to make that information public. KCM is not trying to
keep anything secret, but like every other church in America,
KCM has the right to keep certain things private.
Why did
Rev. John Copeland, on behalf of KCM, go to the IRS and agree
to cooperate with an IRS church tax inquiry? Is KCM willing
to turn over the information sought by Senator Grassley to
the IRS?
Yes. KCM is willing to turn
over the information sought by Senator Grassley to the
IRS. KCM's reasons for approaching the IRS and pledging
to cooperate with a properly conducted church-tax inquiry
can be found in the April 8, 2008, KCM Press Release.
Does KCM undergo
an annual audit by an independent CPA firm? Does KCM make
financial information available to the public?
KCM strives to function with
transparency, accountability and excellence. Financial
information is available through our website: http://www.kcm.org/connect/index.php?p=financial_accountability.
The
church voluntarily submits to an annual audit by an independent
accounting firm.
Who oversees KCM? If KCM has a board of
directors, who serves on the board?
KCM is overseen by its Board
of Directors (the "Board") who consist of Kenneth
and Gloria Copeland, and nine other members. None of
the other Board members is related to the Copelands and none
is employed by the Church. The occupations or callings
of the members of KCM's Board are as follows:
- Oklahoma architect,
- Husband and wife pastors from Minnesota,
- Missouri businessman,
- Texas pastor,
- Husband and wife pastors from Texas,
- Louisiana evangelist, and
- Arkansas businessman.
The Board members are mindful
of their responsibility to act in the best interests of the
Church as an entity, to not allow any person to use Church
resources for personal inurement or benefit, to avoid conflicts
of interest, and to exercise due diligence with respect to
Church affairs.
Who sets the compensation for KCM employees,
including Kenneth and Gloria Copeland? What are the rules
about setting compensation?
The Church has an independent compensation committee, which
approves the compensation of the top officers and employees
of the Church based on data compiled by an independent consulting
firm. None of the independent compensation committee
members is related to the Copelands, and none is employed
by the Church. In addition, they reflect a mix of persons
with business and pastoral backgrounds. Accordingly,
no independent compensation committee member has a conflict
of interest with respect to the compensation arrangements
approved by the committee. Finally, compensation is
approved consistent with procedures established by the Internal
Revenue Code for setting compensation for a tax-exempt organization.
Much
has been made of the home that Kenneth and Gloria live in.
Who owns it? Is it a parsonage?
The Church provides a parsonage to Kenneth and Gloria Copeland
to reside in. In addition to being a residence
for the church's senior pastors, it is also used to
host visiting ministers, Board members, and Church partners.
The parsonage is owned by the Church; neither the Copelands
nor any other individual has any ownership interest in the
parsonage. The Church's independent compensation committee
counts the fair rental value of the parsonage provided to
the Copelands as compensation when it determines whether
the total compensation the Church pays to the Copelands is
reasonable.
Why does KCM own private aircraft? What types
of aircraft are they? Why don't Kenneth and Gloria
fly on commercial airlines?
The Church currently owns three aircraft. These aircraft
are used for various tax-exempt religious purposes. Those
purposes include: worldwide ministry conventions, church
meetings and conferences, prison outreaches, military outreaches,
television tapings, appearances and speaking, disaster relief
ministry, and partner ministry.
The Church's aircraft consist
of: a 1962 Beech H-18 Twin, a 1998 Cessna 550 Citation
Bravo, and a 2005 Cessna 750 Citation X.
The Beech H-18 has not been used to date, as it is still
in the restoration process. It will be used for disaster
relief upon completion of the required repair and maintenance.
The Citation Bravo was donated to KCM near the end of October
2007. The Church uses this plane for Church-related
travel by various ministry team members. For
short distances, this plane is less expensive to use than
the Citation X, but it is too small to be used for international
flights.
The Citation X is used by the Copelands and Church staff
for domestic and international travel to and from Church
events and worldwide ministry conventions.
The Church's decision to purchase private aircraft was
based on the practical demands that the Church's intense
global ministry places on its senior pastors and staff. A
private plane in the context of a busy, global ministry is
not a luxury, but a necessity given the strenuous travel demands
the Church's ministry places on the Copelands. Commercial
travel, with its attendant delays, lost luggage, inferior security,
and lack of privacy, is simply not an option for the Copelands
given the high-profile nature of their ministry and their exhausting
travel schedule. The need for this plane was clearly
recognized by the Church's members, who gave generously
for the specific purpose of ensuring that these tools would
be available to assist the Church in its global ministry |